"there is no explicit material in our schools."
Posted as the district continued removing library books it described as sexually explicit.
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.comCobb Board of Education, Post 4
The record, side by side.
David Chastain and Micheal Garza on the same seven issues. Each line shows what one of them did or said, when, and where it is documented. Votes come from the board record as reported. Positions come from each candidate's own words. Election Day is Tuesday, Nov. 3.
The Chastain File is independent. This page is not affiliated with Keep Cobb Schools Strong, Inc., either campaign, or any committee, is not paid for by anyone, and does not ask anyone to vote for or against either candidate. Updated Oct. 9, 2026.
Their words, face to face
Keep Cobb Schools Strong built its case against Garza from his own posts. Below, each of those posts sits next to Chastain's record on the same subject. Garza's words are quoted from the posts as shown on that site. Chastain's come from his campaign Facebook page and the news reports linked.
"there is no explicit material in our schools."
Posted as the district continued removing library books it described as sexually explicit.
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.comChastain moved to reject a policy that would have created media committees to review challenged books, calling it "micromanaging the superintendent." Rejected 5-2.
Read the article"Cobb County is the epicenter of attacks on public education in Georgia"
Shared with an AJC story on the fallout from the firing of teacher Katie Rinderle.
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.comChastain made the motion to set aside the hearing tribunal's recommendation against firing and uphold the superintendent. Passed 4-3.
Read the article"Removal of the bans on CRT and the 1619 project in Cobb classrooms."
One of the rally demands of the coalition he helped found.
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.com"full throated support to DEI? To CRT?"
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.comChastain voted for the resolution barring both from Cobb classrooms, arguing a concept that hard to define would be hard to teach young children. Four yes, three abstentions.
Read the article"Anti-vaxxers have no place in our state government."
Written in response to a state legislator's post on Senate Bill 345, which bars COVID-19 vaccine mandates in Georgia schools.
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.comChastain defended Superintendent Chris Ragsdale's pandemic response and said he has "done a good job."
Read the articleAsked whether he is confident in the K-9 and Servius programs, Garza said no, citing more than $5 million spent with no effectiveness data on the dogs.
Read the articleAsked why the board never voted on the Servius program, which had been paid nearly $2.6 million, board chair Chastain said "Approving a billion-dollar budget does not mean we vote on every carton (of) milk."
Read the article (via GovTech)Chastain saw no reason to delay the purchase, calling it "fairly cut and dry." Approved 5-2; a 2025 request for data on the dogs' results had not been granted.
Read the article"He sold our students short"
On Ragsdale calling the student walkouts the work of outside political operatives.
Post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.com"Our schools and community need a Stable Hand of Leadership."
His campaign video in the post carries an on-screen caption reading "Outside groups putting our students in Danger," naming the Democratic Socialists of America and the Cobb Democratic Party.
His campaign pageAfter a teacher walkout at a mandatory staff meeting, Chastain said he supported Ragsdale sending a clear message and did not think it would demoralize staff.
Read the articleGarza wrote that Post 4 is a race that could "flip the dynamic of the entire board" and change the district's direction.
Read the article"As you vote, remember: our community can't afford to gamble with success."
His campaign pageChastain ran on "stability, proven results and safety," citing SAT and state test scores.
Read the articleChecked against the record
Six checkable statements from each candidate, each rated on the same scale: True, Mostly true, Half true, Mostly false, or False. Statements of opinion are not rated. Each claim is summarized in plain words, with exact quotes kept to the receipts above, and each rating links to the records it rests on.
The claimCobb has 36 official book bans.
TrueThe district's own list of removed library books showed 36 titles as of April 2025: seven removed in 2023, 25 in 2024, and four in 2025. The district calls them removals, not bans, and says the list grows as reviews continue.
The claimMore than $5 million on two safety programs with no data on the dogs.
TrueReported payments to Servius Group alone reached about $2.6 million by spring 2025, and the district's later quarterly reports add more. The board approved $2 million for eight more dogs in November 2025 and $1.2 million for five more in September 2026. No effectiveness data has been made public. Board member Becky Sayler's request for it was not granted, and the superintendent declined to give details.
The claimThe Servius contract never came before the board.
TrueThe board did not vote on the Servius program. Superintendent Chris Ragsdale said no vote was needed because a state security grant paid for it.
The claimThere is no explicit material in our schools.
Mostly falseBefore the district removed them, school libraries held books with sexually explicit passages, which the district cited when it pulled them. His larger point, that the removals were politically motivated, is an argument about motive, not a fact this check can settle.
The claimThe district fired a teacher for reading an age-appropriate book to her gifted class.
Half trueThe firing over the book is accurate, and a district hearing tribunal recommended against it. Whether the book was age-appropriate is the point in dispute. The state board, a superior court, and in March 2026 the Georgia Court of Appeals all upheld the district's decision.
The claimThe superintendent said the walkouts were the work of outside political operatives.
TrueRagsdale told the board the protests were not student-driven and were coordinated by "well funded adults." Student organizers told reporters they started it themselves. He named no individual adult and gave no funding source.
The claimCampaign graphic: David Chastain, Cobb County School Board Chair.
FalseRandy Scamihorn was elected board chair in January 2026. Chastain is vice chair. He chaired the board in 2025.
The claimThe 2022 campaign finance complaint against him was baseless.
FalseThe state campaign finance commission's June 2023 consent order found two 2022 donations over the limit, $5,500 from Rep. Ginny Ehrhart and $4,000 from attorney Jonathan Crumly. He paid a $250 civil penalty and refunded $2,500. The order records that he admitted the mistake.
The claimCampaign video caption: outside groups, the Democratic Socialists of America and the Cobb Democratic Party, are putting students in danger.
Mostly falseThe Cobb Democratic Party publicly backed students' right to protest peacefully and shared a walkout guide. No report shows it organized the walkouts. The groups the superintendent named were the Party for Socialism and Liberation and Liberation Atlanta, not the Democratic Socialists of America. Student organizers said they ran it themselves. "Putting students in danger" is his opinion.
The claimHe has voted every year to invest well over $30 million annually in student safety.
Half trueThe district's general-fund safety line is about $16.5 million in the FY2027 budget, roughly half his figure. The $30 million-plus number matches a superintendent talking point that no published budget itemizes. Safety money sits inside the annual budget the whole board adopts, usually unanimously, so there is no separate safety vote.
The claimHe opposed letting unelected people decide which library books stay.
Half trueThe policy he moved to reject would have created district media committees to review challenged books. Under the current process the superintendent, also unelected, makes those decisions. Board member Becky Sayler made that point at the meeting.
The claimCobb schools outpace their peers; voters can't afford to gamble with success.
Mostly trueCobb beat the state average in every Milestones subject and grade in 2024-25, and its class of 2026 posted a record graduation rate above 90 percent. The trend is mixed: English scores fell in most grades in 2024-25, and U.S. History proficiency is about 12 points below 2019.
How Cobb compares
How Cobb's schools compare with Georgia and the nation. Where possible, every figure comes from the state's own published data files, so Cobb, Georgia, and the national average are measured the same way.
| Measure | Cobb | Georgia | Nation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Four-year graduation rate, class of 2026 | 90.9% | 88.5% | 87.4% (2022-23, latest national) |
| Average SAT, 2024-25 | 1093 | 1037 | 1029 |
| Average ACT composite, 2024-25 | 23.0 | 21.5 | 19.4 |
| AP exams scored 3 or higher, 2024-25 | 84.9% | 73.7% | n/a |
Sources: graduation, GaDOE 2026 four-year cohort file and the Cobb County Courier; national rate, NCES via K-12 Dive; SAT, ACT, and AP, the state's 2024-25 files at GOSA. The district announced a 2025 SAT average of 1116 and an ACT average of 23.7. The state files measure scores differently (most recent SAT, highest ACT) and put Cobb at 1093 and 23.0.
| Measure | Cobb's place | Who ranks ahead among big districts |
|---|---|---|
| Graduation rate, class of 2026 | 130th of 178 districts; 6th of the 9 largest | Forsyth 97.5%, Cherokee 93.8%, Fulton 93.4%, Henry 92.3%, Atlanta 91.2% |
| Average SAT, 2024-25 | 15th of 171; 3rd of 7 with 1,000+ test-takers | Forsyth 1147, Gwinnett 1110 |
| Average ACT, 2024-25 | 9th of 105 districts | Fulton 24.0 |
| AP exams scored 3 or higher | 84.9% | Forsyth 88.2%, Cherokee 85.2%; ahead of Gwinnett 77.2%, Fulton 75.0% |
Large districts mostly post lower graduation rates than small rural ones, so the overall rank says less than the comparison with similar-size districts. Sources: GaDOE 2026 graduation file; state 2024-25 SAT, ACT, and AP files at GOSA.
A district's average score depends partly on how many students sit for the test. These charts rank 13 metro-area and nearby districts by the share of students tested, with each district's score beside it. Cobb is in yellow; the Georgia average is in gray.
How to read them: Gwinnett tests a smaller share of seniors than Cobb and posts a higher SAT average. Forsyth tests a larger share than Cobb on all three exams and still scores higher on each. DeKalb tests nearly three in four seniors on the SAT, which pulls its average down. On AP, about one in four Cobb high schoolers took at least one exam; Forsyth tested nearly half. Cobb's 84.9 percent AP pass rate is near the top, but districts that test fewer students tend to post higher pass rates. Method: SAT and ACT test-takers divided by fall 2024 12th-grade enrollment; AP students tested divided by fall 2024 enrollment in grades 9 to 12. These are approximations, not official participation rates, and many students take both the SAT and the ACT. Sources: state 2024-25 SAT (most recent score), ACT (highest score), AP, and Enrollment by Grade files at GOSA, compiled by The Chastain File.
| District | Math (gr. 3-8) | Science | Social studies | Algebra | Biology | U.S. History |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cobb | 52.8 | 42.5 | 52.4 | 59.4 | 58.3 | 54.1 |
| Fulton | 56.8 | 48.1 | 52.0 | 60.6 | 59.8 | 45.5 |
| Gwinnett | 53.1 | 54.3 | 51.5 | 57.6 | 50.7 | 40.6 |
| Marietta City | 53.7 | 43.3 | 46.2 | 60.3 | 55.6 | 38.6 |
| City Schools of Decatur | 78.2 | 68.2 | 64.0 | 83.6 | 78.2 | 56.1 |
Five of Cobb's six subjects improved in 2026; none reached 60 percent. English results were withheld statewide this year while the state reset its standards. Cobb leads its big neighbors in U.S. History, but that subject is its weakest recovery: 66.2 percent proficient in 2019, 54.1 percent in 2026. Cobb's lead over the state average in U.S. History shrank every year from 2022 to 2025, from 20.3 points to 16.6. Source: Georgia Milestones files from GaDOE and GOSA, compiled by The Chastain File.
| District | Per-pupil spending, 3-yr avg | 2025 state efficiency rating |
|---|---|---|
| Forsyth | $11,671 | 4.5 stars |
| Cherokee | $12,787 | 4.0 stars |
| Gwinnett | $12,850 | 4.0 stars |
| Cobb | $14,452 | 3.0 stars |
| Marietta City | $17,412 | 2.5 stars |
Sources: GOSA Financial Efficiency Star Rating, 2025 district file; Cobb Schools finance dashboard; Cobb FY2025 annual comprehensive financial report; Georgia Department of Audits school system dashboard.
The district has removed books from school libraries since 2023 under a process run by the superintendent's office.
Made the motion to reject a proposed library policy from board member Becky Sayler. It would have created local and district media committees to review challenged books and protected award-winning titles. He said he did not want unelected people making those calls and called the plan "micromanaging the superintendent."
Source: East Cobb NewsSaid he would reinforce existing book review policies, end what he called "the secret process that has resulted in book bans," and return those decisions to school media specialists.
Source: Cobb County Courier Q&AWrote that Cobb has 36 official book bans and dozens more titles removed informally. That count is his.
Source: Garza essay, EveryLibraryThe district fired Due West Elementary teacher Katie Rinderle after she read a picture book about gender identity to a fifth-grade gifted class.
Made the motion to set aside the hearing tribunal's recommendation and uphold the superintendent's decision to fire her. The tribunal of three retired Cobb administrators found she broke district policy but recommended against firing.
Source: Cobb County CourierSaid district leadership has played into national culture wars, citing the firing of a teacher for reading an age-appropriate book to her gifted class.
Source: Cobb County CourierThe district added vapor wake K-9 teams to high schools and hired an outside threat-monitoring firm, Servius Group.
Agreed with the superintendent that the dogs work better than walk-through detectors, saying not knowing where they will be is a deterrent. Asked how their effectiveness is measured, he said he had not discussed it. On Servius, he said he did not see student targeting as a concern and could not say much more.
Source: Marietta Daily JournalSaid he saw no reason to delay a $1.2 million request for five more dogs and handlers, calling it "fairly cut and dry." A motion to delay failed 4-3 along party lines. Sayler and Davis cast the two no votes; Sayler's November 2025 request for data on the dogs' results had not been granted.
Source: Cobb County CourierSaid he is not confident in either program. He pointed to more than $5 million spent on the two, with no effectiveness data on the dogs, raised concerns about student profiling, and said the Servius contract never went to a board vote. He proposed secure-storage workshops with free gun locks and urging the state to fund more counselors.
Source: Cobb County Courier Q&A"I don't think we should be spending money on unproven solutions."
Source: East Cobb NewsOn the record: in October 2024, Superintendent Chris Ragsdale said the board would not vote on additional funding for Servius Group. Source: Marietta Daily Journal.
Residents can still speak at meetings. The question is whether the public can watch them do it, and who gets to put items on the agenda.
Voted with the Republican majority to stop broadcasting and publishing the public comment portion of board meetings. The superintendent proposed the change, citing legal risk.
Source: Axios AtlantaAs board chair, proposed the policy that ended board members' own comment period, saying some members' remarks had become too political.
Source: East Cobb News (2022 profile)Would restore the broadcast of public comment, allow brief exchanges between board members and speakers, and loosen limits on student comment. Wants to change the rule that lets only the chair or superintendent place items on the agenda on their own.
Sources: Cobb County Courier Q&A; East Cobb NewsIn 2021 the board barred critical race theory and the New York Times 1619 Project from Cobb classrooms.
Voted for the resolution. The three Democratic members abstained in an apparent show of protest. He argued that a concept this hard to define would be hard to teach to young children.
Sources: Cobb County Courier; 11AliveIn a campaign Facebook post defending diversity programs, asked readers whether they would give "full throated support to DEI? To CRT?"
Source: Micheal Garza for Cobb County School Board, Facebook (post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.com)Posted that he was a founding organizer of the coalition whose rally demands included removing the bans on critical race theory and the 1619 Project.
Source: same Facebook page (post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.com)The board hires, evaluates, and extends the superintendent's contract.
Defended Ragsdale's pandemic response and said he has "done a good job."
Source: East Cobb News (2022 profile)After Ragsdale's remarks at a mandatory staff meeting drew a teacher walkout, with about 200 teachers questioned by the district, said he supported the superintendent sending a clear message about the district's direction and did not think it would demoralize staff. He called it a personnel matter and said he did not have full information.
Source: East Cobb NewsSaid the Republican members have been yes-men for Ragsdale for too long. Said he would ask more questions but wants a good working relationship and would not push dramatic action on Ragsdale's job if Democrats won a majority.
Source: East Cobb NewsWrote that Ragsdale's remarks about the student walkouts sold students short by calling the protests the work of outside political operatives.
Source: Micheal Garza for Cobb County School Board, Facebook (post as shown on keepcobbschoolsstrong.com)Fundraising figures come from disclosure reports filed in early August 2026.
Raised about $29,000, with about $17,000 cash on hand. Did not sign the state and county Republican letter demanding Garza return a donor's money.
Source: East Cobb NewsThe state campaign finance commission fined his campaign and ordered refunds for two 2022 donations over the $3,000 limit: $5,500 from state Rep. Ginny Ehrhart, who carried the 2022 map bill, and $4,000 from attorney Jonathan Crumly of Taylor English, the firm hired to draw the map. Chastain said his campaign mistakenly failed to split the contributions between elections and called the complaint baseless.
Source: East Cobb NewsOne of four Republican board members the Finn v. Cobb redistricting lawsuit's amended complaint accused of racially disparate policies. A federal judge dismissed the case as moot in September 2025.
Sources: Spotlight South Cobb News; Cobb County School DistrictRaised about $42,000, with about $16,000 cash on hand. His largest individual donor, Southern Poverty Law Center attorney Michael Tafelski, gave $6,000. Garza refused the Republican leaders' demand that he return it. The Cobb County Association of Educators PAC gave $2,000.
Source: East Cobb NewsNamed a Safe Schools Champion by the Human Rights Campaign, which says the title is not an endorsement.
Source: Cobb County CourierOutside spending: Keep Cobb Schools Strong, Inc., a nonprofit formed Oct. 6, 2026, runs a website opposing Garza. Its registered agent is attorney Bryan Tyson, who drew the 2022 school board map, and it lists his law firm's Marietta office as its address. On Sept. 25, Chastain's campaign page asked supporters to help "keep Cobb County Strong." As of Oct. 9, no committee by the Keep Cobb Schools Strong name was registered with the Georgia Government Transparency and Campaign Finance Commission. Sources: Georgia Secretary of State business record, control no. 26212034; state campaign finance search.
Each entry is drawn from a published news report, the candidate's own writing, or a public record, and links to it. Where a report did not record an individual vote, the entry says only what the report shows. Three Garza Facebook posts are cited as they appear on the Keep Cobb Schools Strong site, because the original posts were not independently viewed; the wording on this page matches those images.
Corrections are welcome and will be noted on this page.
The Chastain File · Independent. Not affiliated with Keep Cobb Schools Strong, Inc., either campaign, or any committee. Not paid for by anyone.